Mail & Guardian Online
THE SMART NEWS SOURCE | Feb 10 2010 00:47 | LAST UPDATED Feb 10 2010 00:47
News | National | Foreign Affairs

Zuma: Zimbabwe is out of control

JOHANNESBURG, SOUTH AFRICA Jun 24 2008 11:18
comments 7 comments | Post your comment


The situation in Zimbabwe is now out of control, African National Congress (ANC) president Jacob Zuma told a conference in Johannesburg on Tuesday.

"You now need a political arrangement there, and then further down the line an election," he said.

He added that the liberation movement values that the ANC once shared with Zanu-PF were no longer there.

"We cannot agree with Zanu-PF. We cannot agree with them on values," Zuma said.

"We fought for the right of people to vote, we fought for democracy."

The African Christian Democratic Party (ACDP), meanwhile, on Tuesday said that the United Nations should put Zimbabwe President Robert Mugabe and his officials on trial in the International Criminal Court for crimes against humanity.

Party leader Reverend Kenneth Meshoe said this was in view of the apparent state-sponsored murder and torture of members of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) and the public in Zimbabwe.

"We are shocked and repulsed by the terror tactics of Mugabe and his forces against a completely defenceless public as displayed in news reports.

"We extend our condolences to those tortured and those who lost loved ones in the political violence."

CONTINUES BELOW


The ACDP said those calling for a government of national unity that included Mugabe were trying to protect a cruel leader from prosecution and should not be taken seriously.

The party also said the decision by the MDC to withdraw from the run-off elections was a courageous one.

The ACDP called on the international community, particularly the African Union and UN, to intervene in the crisis. He said the Southern African Development Community had dismally failed Zimbabweans.

"There must be an immediate end to this senseless violence," he said.

Genocide
Meanwhile, the violence in Zimbabwe could descend into genocide like that in Rwanda in 1994, former international envoy Paddy Ashdown warned on Tuesday.

Military intervention in Zimbabwe had to remain an option, the former high representative for Bosnia told the Times of London, while also lamenting the "thunderous" silence of South African President Thabo Mbeki.

"The situation in Zimbabwe could deteriorate to a point where genocide could be a possible outcome -- something that looks like Rwanda," he said, referring to the slaughter by ethnic Hutus of about 800 000 people, mainly Tutsis.

Ashdown added that were the situation to deteriorate to that point, military intervention, with Britain playing a "delicate role" due to its history as Zimbabwe's former colonial ruler, would have to be an option.

Ashdown, a member of the British Parliament's upper chamber, told BBC radio that diplomatic efforts could still prove fruitful, though Mbeki's role was crucial.

"I think the UN Security Council resolution and the UN secretary general's statement yesterday [Monday] is likely to be influential and have an effect," he said.

"Secondly, the key person in this is Thabo Mbeki, and so far his silence has been thunderous.

"If it were the case that in addition to all the other African friends who have so far supported Mugabe, Mbeki, who is under pressure to do this anyway from within South Africa, were to come out in a very strong statement, I think that would have an effect.

"So there is a diplomatic game to play through here and I think it's not without hope of success."

The comments from the former leader of Britain's opposition Liberal Democrat party came amid increased tension in Zimbabwe, with MDC chief Morgan Tsvangirai taking refuge in the Dutch embassy in Harare.

Senegalese President Abdoulaye Wade, who has called for Zimbabwe's presidential election run-off to be postponed, said soldiers entered the home of Tsvangirai on the weekend, forcing him to flee.

"I learned that soldiers entered Morgan Tsvangirai's home on Sunday June 22, looking for him and that he is only safe because, alerted by friends, he left in a hurry a few minutes earlier," Wade said in a statement.

The Times also reported, without citing its sources, that Britain had two contingency plans with regard to the Zimbabwean election, one of which involved the deployment of troops into the country.

Both the Ministry of Defence and the Foreign Office in London declined to comment on the report when contacted by AFP. -- Sapa, Reuters, AFP
TOPICS IN THIS ARTICLE

Related Articles

Tags

People

Organisations

Comments

"Soldiers came into Mr Tsvangirai home looking for him....."

There's no state of emergency declared yet the military sees fit to run around looking for people.

And we thought this crap only occured in failed states like Somalia!

This shows more than anything else that Zimbabwe is now in legal freefall.
Cliff Smith on June 24, 2008, 1:32 pm
Good on Zuma, to use a turn of phrase I picked up in Ozzie.

He may have a doubtful personal life, but he has more political sense than Mbeki. Let's hope if he does become president, the good sense side prevails.
Philip Machanick on June 24, 2008, 2:02 pm
Robert Mugabe is obsessive compulsive and now also suffers from delusions: only God can remove him from power. Negotiations will all fail. A very bleak future for Zimbabwe. SA can expect an massive influx of people in the near future. The situation is like a crystal ball and the number of deaths will crack the crystal ball and once this happens their will be action. However, it will be too late! Crisis is a test of leadership. To ignore a crisis is a sign that you avoid the test and likely are not worth the leadership role!
Adri Manvselder on June 24, 2008, 2:54 pm
zimbabwe issue presented an oppotunity to zuma to get support. His views are differing with Mbeki's and therefore make him (Zuma) of the views as opposition parties. For him to denounce Mogabe somehow changes the perception that people had on him
Madibolo Mokadi on June 24, 2008, 3:42 pm
It is progress of a sort but we should not get too excited by what Zuma says yet. He is fortunate to have neither the responsibility nor power to do anything about Zim at present and cannot miss in letting his political adversary, Mbeki, continue to take the heat.
Paul Whelan on June 24, 2008, 4:36 pm
I sometimes wonder if it’s worth having the United Nations it is really a useless body when it comes to certain world issues. In October of 2002 the council published a damning report about Mugabe and his cabal of criminals’ illegal exploitation of natural resources of Congo Kinshasa (DRC). The panel concludes on widespread illegal operations spearheaded by the Ugandan and Rwandan occupiers and the Kinshasa government together with its Zimbabwean ally. The panel recommended sanctions against several companies and persons involved in the illegal businesses.
The people of Zimbabwe are being massacred to protect these illicit deals and just wonder if the our lame Pres. Mbeki has his fingers in the cookie jar and is afraid of exposure should he speak loud.
What was the purpose of compiling this report when it could not be acted upon, President Bush was right on his assessment of this body and went into Iraq, I hope and sincerely he can be persuaded to go to Harare and flush out Osama bin Laden who is in Sanctuary there. Never mind there not being weapons of mass destruction in Iraq at least he got one tyrant out.
mpho mkhalipi on June 24, 2008, 7:11 pm
I agree that Mr Zuma is in a fortunate position. He is not the mediator. Not many countries can blast and appear the honest broker at the same time. The ANC statement if analysed said nothing new and in fact was the Biblical Pilate washing his hands of the problem.

That Mr Mbeki was negotiating all along and that there were reforms at one point seems to indicate a realisation that something was amiss. That he failed to change Mugabe who has realised that he nearly buried himself by allowing a near semblance of democracy is something else. Yes perhaps South Africa has not fully empowered its majority economically which could lead to a diffidence in tackling somebody strutting about as a true liberator. That is the case with almost many any African President. The diffidence to stand by their policies and the belief in them and their success. The strengthening of their own institutions. Zuma is skirting on thin ice. It would be something to hear a mudslinging match between Mugabe and Zuma. One is in need of a trial to clear his name and the other is in need of a free and fair election to legitimise them. But both of them seem determined to do the darndest best to rejest the legitimising processes. Incidentally their supporters talk the same lannguage.

No Mr Zuma, zimbabwe was always out of control. Even when you were cheering Robert Mugabe's invasion of farms. even last year when Kgalema Montlanthe wrote the article about illegal sanctions it was out of control. Even when Cyril Ramaphosa feasted at the ZANU PF congress to a Polokwane like endorsement of Robert Mugabe's candidature following mass actions by war vets or marches and ostracising of those seen to be in opposition it was already out of control.

What we are seeing is a denouement of the plot which at various stages of history Britain and recently the ANC helped script. At the moment they, for all condemnation of the most unfortunate individual on earth at the moment (Thabo Mbeki)have nothing to offer save condemnation. It is my view that if SADC wanted South Africa leverage to flex its muscle, it should have chosen another nation to mediate with South Africa on the side. Right now it must be seen to be neutral for all its worth to get through the charade of buying confidence. Robert Mugabe knows that the refugee problem could be worse for South Africa if it closed off supplies and would be inhumane. Him and his cronies will still be living lasrge in Zimbabwe Ruins.
william sithonga on June 25, 2008, 2:20 pm
You must be logged in to comment. Log in or sign up to comment
click here to log in

M&G Online Comment Guidelines In Brief

  • No hate speech;
  • No racist, sexist or homophobic remarks;
  • Keep it short;
  • Keep it on topic;
  • Show respect to all;
  • We reserve the right to remove or delete any comment without notice or reason.

Click here for the full Comment Guidelines

Advertising Links



LATEST ARTICLES IN THIS SECTION
POPULAR ARTICLES IN THIS SECTION
Kalahari.net
2,3-million titles to choose from.
iPod nano 16GB - Black, Was R2,499.00 Now R2,299.00! Save R200!
46 000 DVDs and Blu-Ray on sale now!
100s of new releases now in stock. Get the new Sade & Bon Jovi albums.
Widest toy range and unbeatable prices!




Follow the Mail & Guardian on Twitter!


Direct message us on our mailandguardian account to chat to the M&G Online team.
THIS WEEK'S PAPER

Advertisements


Advertising links