THE SMART NEWS SOURCE | Feb 10 2010 07:41 | LAST UPDATED Feb 10 2010 07:41 |
|
Irene Grootboom died this week, penniless and homeless in her shack in Wallacedene. It is an image at odds with the photograph of her we publish in this edition: in it she spreads her arms in victory. She smiles, perhaps thinking of the home that might one day be hers. The Grootboom judgement to which she lent her name has become shorthand for one of post-apartheid South Africa's major pro-poor victories. It gives extra muscle to the Constitution's socio-economic rights -- specifically the right to shelter -- by compelling the government to take action. The ruling has set precedents for other judgements on the socio-economic rights of South Africans. That Grootboom died in her shack, her victory unrealised, at the beginning of women's month should shame us all and goad the government into renewed commitment. Her death is a poignant symbol of the development failures of a middle-income country with a budget surplus, which for eight years could not provide proper shelter for a woman whom the Constitutional Court ruled it should immediately house. And, in the week of her death, what was our government doing? Half of it was in Pietermaritzburg dissing the high court for "persecuting" ANC president Jacob Zuma. The delegation included Housing Minister Lindiwe Sisulu, who told us that the ministerial handbook allows party work. Sure. The other half was furiously defending President Thabo Mbeki against allegations that he channelled payola to the ruling party from the arms deal. On both sides there is a deeply worrying conflation of party and state imperatives, which leaves most South Africans out in the cold and allows the likes of Grootboom to die in a shack. With the attention and energy of our public representatives distracted by internal party politicking, they have forgotten that their first duty is to the poor. In Parliament the same trend is visible. Despite widespread civil society opposition to the dissolution of the Scorpions, ANC apparatchiks tell us that they are accountable only to the party. Zuma has every right to defend himself by using every legal avenue. But as a leader, he is also responsible for ensuring that his and his supporters' actions do not terminally damage the country he so desperately wants to lead. One of his most fanatical backers, South African Communist Party secretary general Blade Nzimande, was quoted this week warning that he would take the country to the brink if Zuma's case was not dropped. The single-minded struggle to ensure that Zuma moves into the Union Buildings has spawned a massive campaign of intimidation of the judiciary and other democratic institutions, which looks set to dominate the political landscape over at least the medium term. The country's real priorities, like those symbolised by Grootboom, look set to stay on the backburner -- despite the fact that the post-Polokwane ANC projects itself as a party back in touch with the people. ANC president Jacob Zuma must be left to fight his battles on his own. He is not a victim of judicial persecution; he faces a bog-standard corruption trial. If he cares for his country, he should entreat his party and allies to start fighting the battles that really matter to South Africans. Zim: let the people speak The Zimbabwe power-sharing negotiation is far from ideal. There ought not to have been a need for such a process: the March presidential elections that saw Morgan Tsvangirai emerge victorious but without enough votes to secure him leadership of that nation should have been a cue as to whom Zimbabweans want as their leader. It would have been helpful if the negotiations had included more civil society representatives and more political players than the triumvirate that is Zanu-PF and the two MDC factions. These were tricky circumstances and we are not blind to the reality that issues such as the guarantee of property rights, land distribution and the drawing-up of a Constitution will have to be tackled head-on to make outcomes of the Pretoria talks meaningful and lasting. Most certainly families of victims of political violence will want justice for themselves and their loved ones, killed and maimed by Robert Mugabe's band of brigands. The shuttle diplomacy between Pretoria and Harare will need to provide answers to those families who have lost their land and property. Zimbabwe is on the cusp of a new order. By definition, such times are tense and uncertain, and cynicism under these conditions seems a reasonable reflex. But our responsibility as neighbours and as members of the international community is to offer the people of Zimbabwe our support, not our cynicism. The electoral system in Zimbabwe has failed to give expression to the will of the people. The international community will be guilty of the same offence if it disregards the opinion of Zimbabweans and what they are willing to live with. Without being prescriptive, we hope that the people of Zimbabwe will not only accept a transitional order, but will also see this as an opportunity to create a new culture that does away with the impunity that has survived the transition from Ian Smith's regime to Mugabe's, the latter's starting with the wanton, mass slaughter of the Ndebeles in the 1980s. The best the rest of the international community can and should do is take lessons from Zimbabwe so that it never again allows another prosperous country to descend into the abyss while it watches. Also read TOPICS IN THIS ARTICLE
Comments
Vince York on August 8, 2008, 1:01 pm
Indeed, RIP Irene Grootboom. Her plight and undignified end is surely and indictment on governments both past and present.
One can’t help be amazed at the hysterical, steamroller approach by the ANC in endeavouring to fast track Mr. Zuma into the hot seat at the Union Buildings. I wonder, did those ANC heavyweights in their support of brother Jacob in court the other day, apply for a days leave? Surely the lines are not that blurred between government official business and ANC support duties.
Colin Drew on August 8, 2008, 2:54 pm
Whether we like it or not Zumageddon is coming - he has the support of the majority of the ANC (not the majority of South Africans) and the ANC will not lose power in the foreseeable future.
However few if any journalists have taken up the cudgel that was offered by Madiba to clobber Zuma when Nelson Mandela paid a surprise visit to a hospice near Alexandra in Johannesburg on Monday. Mandela told the children how important education was. "Today, no person who is not well educated can lead the country. So you must attach importance to education because that's the only way you can be accepted as a leader." Zuma most certainly is not well educated and so, according to the continent's most respected leader,he can not be accepted as a leader. Which, of course, means he should not be leader of the ANC let alone President of our country.
Bill Richards on August 8, 2008, 5:32 pm
I have to admit that Zuma is not one of my favourate menus but he has rights just like all of us do so you are very wrong Richard.
The honest truth about the South Africa we are living in is a lack of credible leaders.I hoped that Motlanthe would rise above the challenge and be a man to lead south Africa but as the saying goes "birds of the same feather fly together.He seems to be too weak or too afraid of losing the deputy presidency if he doesn't come strong on the attack of the so called Anti-revolution institutions. Its clear that the ANC lacks the kind of leaders that are needed to take South Africa forward but it will be wrong to accuse people who are going to vote it to the Presidency of idiocy.But let's hang on there,surely we wont go down with them,the cracks are already showing so at the end justice will prevail,and we will say Long Live South Africa.
Lucas Thatelo on August 8, 2008, 11:12 pm
Leaders are born,they do not have to be educated.A wise leader will always seek the company of the elite to run the country effiency.
People will like this person because of what he is,possesing leadrship characteristics.It is very difficult to desert the people who always admire and appreciate the way you handle their problems. Running into Union Building does not mean that you will be working alone.You pick up people whom you think will help you accomplish the goals of helping the nation,but only to find that you will be surrounded by the most culprit in the country. The point is, we should not judge people,say they not educated and not fit to be presidents.
Sibusiso Maphanga on August 9, 2008, 2:33 pm
The country's real priorities ANC style are self first, party second and if there is time left we can look at what we can do for the poor etc. Esentially we are a 1 party state, the opposition has no voice and nor do the public. The majority of the educated population providing that you are not a thief or a corrupt politician want the scorpions to remain but no matter what the public outcry they will be dibanded.
Zuma's profile is been elevated by the ANC executive to harness more votes because they know that the present government has been exposed as a bunch of corrupt, selfish and incompetent self serving rogues. Through Zuma, Vavi and Malema they are targeting a section of the population that they know will carry them in the next elections. Even the blind can see that.
Joe Irwin on August 9, 2008, 4:04 pm
Thank you for an interesting article highlighting what I, a foreigner, see as 'two solitudes'. The DA and other like-minded souls seeing issues as 'right or wrong', with wrong being punished; and the ANC and associates, seeing 'persecution, humiliation and embarrassment'. It is difficult to see how these two views can be reconciled into policies and leadership which will move South AFrica forward, so that the poor are cared for and the homeless sheltered with dignity. Concerning Zimbabwe where I now live:"The international community will be guilty of the same offence if it disregards the opinion of Zimbabweans and what they are willing to live with.", the most common and vocal comment I hear these days is 'who does the MDC (of various stripes) think they are? No one is consulting ordinary Zimbabweans to see what THEY want out of these talks; more politicos of the ANC type feathering their nests, is the talk from the street. Please do NOT blame this, once again, on 'the international community', this appears to be ANC helping its brother clones.
LA QUEBECOISE on August 10, 2008, 10:53 am
click here to log in
M&G Online Comment Guidelines In Brief
Advertising Links
|
2,3-million titles to choose from.
iPod nano 16GB - Black, Was R2,499.00 Now R2,299.00! Save R200!
46 000 DVDs and Blu-Ray on sale now!
100s of new releases now in stock. Get the new Sade & Bon Jovi albums.
Widest toy range and unbeatable prices!
AdvertisementsAdvertising links |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||







More important than the nation?????
Judiciary worth S**** in eyes of gov & nation, police too corrupt to carry out it's instructions anyway, and the fight is on for those comrades who have been left out in the cold with no taste of the GRAVY.
Let gov & big business spend the country flat, but use age old instruments to subjugate the ordinary citizen into permanent bankruptcy to pay for their big spend. Civil servants get paid completely out of proportion, for doing nothing - no forward planning, no vision, no preparation, no maintenance. Only financial institutions and gov have never felt the brunt of an empty tum!
Whose nxt for President - Judas Mamela?
Indeed RIP rsa.