THE SMART NEWS SOURCE | Feb 10 2010 06:39 | LAST UPDATED Feb 10 2010 06:39 |
|
South Africa should not withhold aid to Zimbabwe because of what had happened with donations in the past, Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) spokesperson Nelson Chamisa said on Monday. "This is a new administration. It's a clean pair of hands," he said. He was speaking as SADC [Southern African Development Community] ministers gathered in Cape Town for a meeting expected to discuss the size and shape of a massive aid package to the crippled country. According to Zimbabwe's government-owned Herald newspaper, nine legislators -- two from Zanu-PF and the rest from the MDC -- have been named as being party to the misappropriation of fertiliser and seed sent to the country last year as part of a R300-million South African agricultural aid package. The country's new prime minister, MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai, last week said his country could need as much as about R50-billion in aid, and South African President Kgalema Motlanthe has said South Africa is prepared to take the lead in any financial rescue package. Chamisa, speaking from Harare, said on Monday that the MDC was investigating the allegation that some of its MPs were involved in the agricultural aid fraud. However the seven had all denied wrongdoing. "From preliminary findings it would appear it's a big hoax meant to paint us in a negative picture," he said. He said even if there had been misuse of the aid, it was no reason to hold back on a larger aid package. "You can't crucify Mr Tsvangirai or anybody on the basis of the past." It was reported in a weekend newspaper that a SADC task force had completed a probe into the allegations of misuse. However, South African government spokesperson Themba Maseko said that as far as he was aware the report had not been finished. He did not believe the affair would influence South Africa's willingness to commit to more aid. "We don't know what happened with that money, so we are still waiting for a report on that," he said. South African government departments were also compiling their own report on how the R300-million had been spent, he said. Zimbabwe media says substantial quantities of fertiliser and maize seed sent to the country as part of the R300-million package were "looted". SADC secretariat officials are in Cape Town for the formal council of ministers meeting that starts on Wednesday. However, getting information from them about the body's report on the agricultural aid, and in fact about anything, proved an insuperable challenge. -- Sapa TOPICS IN THIS ARTICLE
Comments
Solidarity has a price. Time to come to the table ladies and gentlemen.
Temba Hove on February 23, 2009, 3:46 pm
So presumably Mr Nelson Chamisa is content that his statement quote you can't crucify Mr Tsvangarai or anybody on the basis of the past unquote can also be applied to Mr Mugabe and all the other Zanu-PF leadership
Anthony Dalton on February 23, 2009, 5:49 pm
Yes, and solidarity for Zimbabwe means a government that the people and the international community can trust. This is something that the MDC and SADC should have understood when they manufactured this agreement. Until Zimbabwe demonstrates a departure from its past and a renewed commitment to building a country based on integrity and yes, real solidarity, the whole world and its own people in the diaspora will just watch and wait. It will take more than tokenism to achieve that. You will have to face up to the traversties of the past and make restitution, neither man nor God can honour your new government until you do. This is not a time to sweep the past under the carpet, it will just stay there to haunt you. This takes more than words, it demands real actions and commitment.
Andrew Lawrence on February 23, 2009, 6:50 pm
Well now, let's see.
Farm invasions are still happening. MDC can't get its people out of jail where they are languishing under trumped up charges. The first tranche of aid, R300million Rands worth is largely unaccounted for. Gono is disputing that anything is going to change with Zimbabwe's monetary policy. MDC pooh-poohs any kind of controls on aid - "we're not children". So on the face of it, nothing has changed except that Zimbabwe now has a bloated cabinet - almost twice the size of the largest European economy, Germany. We would need our collective heads read if we didn't hold back. I want to see that the MDC really does have a say in governing Zim - let them prove themselves by, for example: - Firing Gideon Gono - Freeing the activists still being held by the police - Respecting the SADC farm invasion judgments and stopping the farm invasions and protecting the few productive farms that are left. - Accepting independent oversight of how the aid is to be spent. And in any case aid presupposes that South African taxpayers are happy to contribute. And therein lies another source of annoyance. If our esteemed government and in particular our spectacularly ineffective SADC mediator president had applied the pressure that we so easily could have - public statements of disapproval escalating to the odd blackout via Eskom - Zim wouldn't have descended quite so far into the mire and it wouldn't cost so very much to help them out. But of course, at the end of the day, we'll be happy to help our brothers and sisters in Zimbabwe - we must. It's our duty. But kindly prove first that our money isn't going to go straight into the pockets of "president" Mugabe's henchmen/controllers.
Rob Mousley on February 23, 2009, 6:54 pm
gde prime minister give yourself time. we know you are in this with a positive mind but remember we are dealing with ZANU PF. don't forget what they mean when they say ZANU PF ndeye ropa (ZANU PF is made of people's blood)
moses mafusire on February 23, 2009, 9:18 pm
It's not a "new administration" and nor does it have "clean hands". It's an administration presided over by the same old obscenity called Mugabe and old leopards do not change their spots. No handouts until Mugabe is gone.
Jon Low on February 24, 2009, 1:10 am
I thought the MDC had a problem with South Africa and SADC....... Now who are they approaching for help?
Clayton Majona on February 24, 2009, 9:10 am
R300m Not Accounted For? Manuel, Tito & Motlanthe, welcome to the world of Gonomics!! You give us aid, we take-out three quarters for Grace & Sekuru Handiende's shopping holiday to Hong Kong, the 85th birthday bash and of course 4x4s for the super-patriots?
So you South Africans thought it was just opposition politics when we told you that Bob & his cronies cannot be trusted? Now all the aid has been salted away to foreign accounts in Asia and destitute Zimbabweans are still dying from cholera & starvation. Can you continue to shout ''interference!!'' when the West put conditions and demand accountability for their aid. Surely there has to be a paper/audit trail on the transfer & utilisation of the funds which will pinpoint where the buck stops - those are the people who should cough-up. Do you think South African tax-payers will be happy to hear that their hard-earned Rand went on to line the pockets of the Zim fat-cats? Wake up and smell the coffee gentlemen. And Mutambara,what have you got to say about all this?
Tsvimbo Dzemoto on February 24, 2009, 10:18 am
click here to log in
M&G Online Comment Guidelines In Brief
Advertising Links
|
2,3-million titles to choose from.
iPod nano 16GB - Black, Was R2,499.00 Now R2,299.00! Save R200!
46 000 DVDs and Blu-Ray on sale now!
100s of new releases now in stock. Get the new Sade & Bon Jovi albums.
Widest toy range and unbeatable prices!
AdvertisementsAdvertising links |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||






