Mail & Guardian Online
THE SMART NEWS SOURCE | Feb 09 2010 23:20 | LAST UPDATED Feb 09 2010 23:20
News | National | Government

Opposition: Zuma long on intentions, short on action

CAPE TOWN, SOUTH AFRICA Jun 03 2009 17:49
comments 13 comments | Post your comment


Opposition leaders were quick to dismiss President Jacob Zuma's State of the Nation address in Parliament on Wednesday as "a wish list".

The Democratic Alliance (DA), the Inkatha Freedom Party (IFP) and the Congress of the People (Cope) all agreed that the speech was long on good intentions, but seriously short of substance.

For Cope, their first deputy president Mbhazima Shilowa categorised the address as more of the same, with a lot of missed opportunities.

"Everything was about what we will ensure rather than a programme of action for the next five years," he said.

For the DA, Parliamentary leader Athol Trollip said the reduction of red tape which is stifling small enterprises said nothing at all about the labour regulations.

"Labour is often the most stifling issue. Labour and its policies make it almost impossible for small businesses to survive in this kind of environment," he said.

Trollip was also concerned about creeping socialism -- especially in relation to agrarian reform. He suggested that perhaps that was a sop to his left-wing supporters in return for some labour concession.

Helen Zille, the DA party leader and Western Cape premier, was most anxious about the determination Zuma expressed to press ahead with the unified civil service.

"It will make government more and more centralised and will undermine the independence of local governments," she said.

Mangosuthu Buthelezi, the leader of the IFP, said he regarded the speech as an expression of intent, rather than a detailed programme of action.

But he had praise for the intention to uplift the poor.

CONTINUES BELOW


"That resonates very well with us," he said, but he noted that Zuma also warned that it might be difficult to implement that because of "the global meltdown".

The general secretary of the Congress of South African Trade Unions, Zwelinzima Vavi, said he was worried about what the president said on reducing the bureaucracy stifling small businesses.

"We want to hear the details of what that means," Vavi said, "because in the past that term was used in a most problematic fashion, in a way that was interpreted to mean that the workers in those businesses have their rights reduced."

Nehawu endorses government commitment to manifesto
Meanwhile, Zuma's confirmation that government was committed to implementing the ANC's manifesto was welcomed by the National Education Health and Allied Workers' Union (Nehawu).

One of the points Zuma made was that in spite of the country's shrinking economy, the plans that the ANC placed before the electorate would remain at the core of the government's programme.

In reaction, Nehawu said it fully supported this stance.

"We endorse and support the government's overarching stance that the current economic crisis will not cause any change in the content of the programme and that the government is committed to implement the ANC's manifesto with speed and determination."

The union added that it hoped to engage with government on its Medium Term Strategic Framework for 2009 to 2014 as presented by Zuma in his speech.

Nehawu said it welcomed government's commitment to speed up the establishment of a single public service as well as its commitment to the introduction of a National Health Insurance scheme.

The union added it was commendable that Zuma had committed the R787-billion infrastructure expenditure not only to public enterprises, but also towards the poor.

Zuma announced in his speech that the money would also be spent on the school building programme, public transport, including the bus rapid transit system, housing, water and sanitation.

Nehawu also lauded Zuma's intention to combat corruption.

The union, however, said it was concerned that there had been no mention of the implementation of all the outstanding Occupation Specific Dispensations as well as the filling of all funded vacancies in the public service in line with government's previous commitments.

Nehawu added that while it welcomed Zuma's pledge on job creation, it was worried about the "silence" over the commitment made in the Medium Term Budget Policy Statement in October 2008 when government stated that it had set aside R4-billion to create 155 000 permanent jobs each year up until 2011.

"We require clarity on this," the union said.

Clarification was also required on Zuma's pledge to create a Border Management Agency "because of its potential implications for workers currently working at border posts as part of the public service", Nehawu said.

Zuma has "clear vision" for SA
Agri SA said on Wednesday that Zuma's address was to the point and testament to his "clear vision" for South Africa in Africa.

"Striking was the absence of political rhetoric and conspicuous a clear awareness of the problems the world economy and South Africa are contending with," the organisation's president Johannes Moller said in a statement.

The agriculture sector was assuredly not apathetic towards poverty, unemployment and the recession Zuma focused on in his address to Parliament, Moller said.

Agriculture was proudly making more than positive contributions in all these areas.

"We want to build further on agriculture's good record in this regard, particularly that of the recent past."

With rural areas essentially the domain of agriculture, Moller found Zuma's focus on rural development and the development and improvement of infrastructure of particular interest.

He also confirmed that the renewed focus on the prevention of crime would receive the "biggest possible support" of organised agriculture.

In its statement, Agri SA said it took notice of the emphasis Zuma placed on international relations, African development, cooperation in the Southern African Development Community and the economic problems in Zimbabwe.

Moller said Agri SA was presently analysing and obtaining a mandate from its members on its possible role in this respect. -- I-Net Bridge, Sapa
TOPICS IN THIS ARTICLE

Related Articles

Tags

Organisations

Comments

If Pres.Zuma is serious about finding employment for the disadvantaged and presently unemployed masses, there are a couple of wonderful opportunities for him - disaster management and environmental reparation and maintenance. These are two public services that will become increasingly important as global warming and climate change start intensifying. He could employ half a million during the course of this year for intensive skills training to form two dedicated and permanent task units. We are familiar with disaster management functions but environmental reparation and maintenance is not so well understood. A permanent force dedicated to these tasks could start paying for itself very quickly. It could start by focussing upon our most precious commodity - water - by clearing and cleaning up our rivers and wetland regions, locating illegal toxic waste dumping sites and industrial contamination activities and, with appropriate authority prosecute offenders. With 250 000 new recruits every year for the next five years, this particular unit could create specialised sub-sets concentrating upon the various types of environmental contamination, not least of all safe sanitation and clean water needs in rural areas throughout the country.
A healthier environment will be rewarded by healthier lives, reduced sickness and medical expenses, increased productivity and greatly improved tourist attraction.
By having these two units fully trained and equipped, proactively engaged in their particular functions, we shall be ready to meet global warming and climate change fully prepared.

Bob Robertson on June 4, 2009, 1:09 am
Zille's farcical assertion that the govt. intend moving towards a more centralised state and therefore erode the power of the Provinces, should be dismissed with the contempt it deserve. By this statement this woman prove that she is more interested in power for herself and party. This woman should remember there are more important issues that must be dealt with like an economy that is shrinking worldwide, a one not of the govt.'s doing but by the greed of the champions of capitalism in the capitals of North America and Western Europe! Zille is the leader of an opposition with 15% of the vote and therefore her views cannot guide our country's future political discourse! The poor, marginalised, unemployed and others demand national govt. intervention in all areas of governance, whether it is in Zille's backyard in the WC or not!
Freddie Fillis on June 4, 2009, 8:04 am
I think that the government, and opposition parties, are missing a golden opportunity in the midst of the "Global Economic Crisis". It is my humble opinion that we may be witnessing the demise of capitalism as we know and understand it. Greed has been the catalyst that has led us to this point, and there may be no way around it this time. With climate change and all manner of political strife all over the globe, I think its time that we rethink our strategies for living at a very fundamental level. We need to be concentrating on models for sustainable living, alternative energy and perhaps an entirely new cultural model that we can begin to coax our children into. If we don't find new and revolutionary solutions to the survival hurdles that face us, we may not have to worry about the "Global Economic Crisis" for much longer because the Global Economy may collapse! It is insane to keep on throwing the same solutions at the age old problems and expect a different result. Lets get together as Africans, who are not as deeply entrenched in the western roller coaster ride, and invent new planet friendly ways to deal with the challenges facing us. Jobs are not a feasible way of circumventing the issues at hand, real sustainable village living IS. Think Permaculture (Google it if you don't know what it is!). Think Hybrid Economy. Think letting go of what you know, and let your mind wonder outside of the box. Lets move away from our beloved Calvanist work ethic and be more creative and eco-friendly, please President Zuma!
Persona Obscura on June 4, 2009, 8:40 am

Whingers & whiners, they shall remain forever disgruntled and dissatisfied.
Pathetic 10% parties...
Siphiwo Siphiwo, service delivery now on June 4, 2009, 9:47 am
Bob, I couldn't agree with you more. That is a really good idea! I knew there were people out there capable of thinking outside of the box. How can we get the man to listen? Maybe its up to us to make it happen? Governments all over the world are known for their inability to act. May the Force be with you!
Persona Obscura on June 4, 2009, 9:49 am
Hey SS dude! I have been reading through your comments all over this site. It seems to me that you are the whinger & whiner really. You have such a negative commentator, especially when it comes to comments which you perceive to be coming from "white" africans. I love being a South African and my interest in politics is that the correct path be taken. I am not interested in the race or beliefs of the person in power, just that they make all of our lives better. I wish that you and your ilk would get over yourselves and start contributing to a more positive and meaningful future. Analyse carefully the other comments on this article and maybe you will find some inspiration for your life!
Persona Obscura on June 4, 2009, 12:12 pm
Freddie, get over yourself and your various and sundry 'chips'. The ANC won the election in 6 out of 7 provinces. Don't you think they have enough of the country to take care of and show us what they can do. After all they control the government and all the ministries, that should give them a pretty good headstart. I say competition is good for everyone, nobody does well when there is a monopoly, economic or political.
Andrew Lawrence on June 4, 2009, 8:21 pm
@ Freddie and Siphiwo; can you explain the ANC's increasingly vocal noises about doing away with provincial governments etc, if they are not intending to centralise power?

All I hear is racist attacks on HZ, but no explanations of how centralising power can benefit us. I am convinced it won't, but am interested to hear a good case for the centralisation of power. If you have a good arguement for, then please put it forward. I have explained why I don't believe it is a good idea on previous posts. I'd like to hear the potential benefits from your perspective?
Nahor Ecnarraf on June 5, 2009, 10:46 am
@ Nahor. I don't think you will get much of a response from SS. He gives the impression, intentionally or otherwise, that original ideas are forbidden territory.
While centralised government is a highly charged subject, I believe the absence of centralised party discipline and accountability is an issue for debate.
All too often accountability at ANC controlled Municipal levels is conspicuous by its absence, regardless of demands for participative governance directed from national level. As important as national governance obviously is, the main thrust of nationwide service delivery must be at the Municipal level. This is the level at which the country's voters live and work and, this is where service delivery is so desperately needed. Unfortunately, from practical experience, calls upon Provincial government to intercede on one's behalf have no effect. There appears to be a policy of detached autonomy playing out at all three levels of governance with no evidence of centralised policing and admonishment from the top down.
Regardless of party political leadership at Provincial and Local levels, service delivery excellence at all Municipal levels must prevail and, centralised governance should be granted the power to ensure that it does.


Bob Robertson on June 6, 2009, 1:01 am
Thanks Bob - I guess that's a fair point; I think my concern comes from centralising power in ANC hands more than anything else. If they weren't all so tainted by corruption and mismanagment, then I'd probably feel less worried about it all. My concern is that the anc would steer recources away from non ANC aligned communities, and look after their own supporters only. It mght be paranoia, but my Dad had similar concerns about Mugabe's centralisaton of power in Zim, prompting a move to SA; unfortunatly he was proven correct.
Nahor Ecnarraf on June 7, 2009, 3:35 am
The ANC has been talking about the poor for over 10 years. Today there are more poor than there were 10 years ago, and by next year there will still be more poor as well.
ross gordon on June 7, 2009, 7:57 pm
@Nahor
Your point is well taken but Mugabe and his gang are something else. Even I, a devoit pesimist, would be loath to compare his despotic psyche to that of the ANC. JZ, from his position as president has broadcast loud and clear his intention to combat corruption at all levels. He could get a doctorate on the subject, so we must assume he is aware of what has been going on at all levels of government and will take steps to stamp it out from this point forward. He knows his declarations of sound governance will be recorded by international observers so he will be more anxious than before to protect his presidential integrity.
The most recent revelations of corruption in high places have provided an excellent opportunity for him to convert promises into action. The world will be watching, and waiting.
Bob Robertson on June 15, 2009, 10:28 pm
Zille wil fail the W.Cape cz service delivery has no connectioin with talkin very much and is something that even her media friends can not help her about
Martin Radebe on June 17, 2009, 6:29 am
You must be logged in to comment. Log in or sign up to comment
click here to log in

M&G Online Comment Guidelines In Brief

  • No hate speech;
  • No racist, sexist or homophobic remarks;
  • Keep it short;
  • Keep it on topic;
  • Show respect to all;
  • We reserve the right to remove or delete any comment without notice or reason.

Click here for the full Comment Guidelines

Advertising Links



LATEST ARTICLES IN THIS SECTION
POPULAR ARTICLES IN THIS SECTION
Kalahari.net
2,3-million titles to choose from.
iPod nano 16GB - Black, Was R2,499.00 Now R2,299.00! Save R200!
46 000 DVDs and Blu-Ray on sale now!
100s of new releases now in stock. Get the new Sade & Bon Jovi albums.
Widest toy range and unbeatable prices!




Follow the Mail & Guardian on Twitter!


Direct message us on our mailandguardian account to chat to the M&G Online team.
THIS WEEK'S PAPER

Advertisements


Advertising links